How do you determine if an accommodation is reasonable? An accommodation is considered reasonable if it does not: affect an essential component of the course of study or the primary purpose of the test constitute a fundamental alteration of the class compromise the integrity of the test cause undue financial or administrative hardship pose a safety or health threat to the student or others Reasonable adjustments must be made unless the faculty determines that granting the accommodation would compromise "essential" elements in the curriculum. Thus, in a college or university setting, these laws mandate reasonable accommodations for students with learning disorders such as extended testing time and texts in alternate formats in the same way that it mandates curb cuts and ramped entrances for students with physical disabilities. Remember, standards are not subject to accommodation. Methods of evaluation and delivery are subject to accommodation. What is not acceptable is doing nothing. We must decide how we can accommodate in a way that is not an undue burden, does not affect the integrity of the test or fundamentally alter the course and does not cause a financial hardship. Salome M. Heyward, a consultant on disability issues and the author of Access to Education for the Disabled states "There are no absolute responsibilities for institutions. Instead the law is forcing people to strike a new balance among the interests of all involved." When determining if a student's requested accommodation is reasonable, ask: Does it affect an essential component of the course? affect the primary purpose of the test? constitute a fundamental alteration of the class? compromise the integrity of the test? cause undue financial hardship? cause undue administrative hardship? pose a safety threat to the student or others? pose a health threat to the student or others? If the answer to any of the above questions is "yes," another accommodation should be considered. Call a SNAP administrator (953-1431) if you and the student need assistance in determining an appropriate accommodation. Back to the Guide

Contact CDS

Updated 9/23/08